{ "kind": "hwanse-non-palette-motion-producer-review", "status": "battle-motion-grounded-map-tile-motion-producer-unbound", "source": [ "out/palette_pipeline_review.json", "out/map_animation_execution_boundary_review.json", "out/map_animation_live_buffer_writer_review.json", "out/map_animation_frame_script_tile_write_review.json", "out/map_animation_non_object_tile_write_root_review.json", "out/battle_helper_position_motion_review.json", "out/battle_effect_animation_pattern_review.json", "out/battle_effect_visual_assertion_review.json" ], "summary": { "mapConclusion": "Map-side non-palette visible tile motion is still unbound: live tile writer handlers exist, but no static path currently ties them to animated map roots/cells or the field tick route.", "battleConclusion": "Battle-side non-palette effect motion is substantially grounded through helper position/motion fields, spawn streams, and visual runner assertions, with the explicit boundary that it is not yet an original runtime pixel oracle.", "mapSummary": { "animatedMapCount": 5, "animatedCellCount": 1200, "liveBufferCandidateVmTileWriteRefCount": 6, "liveBufferAnimatedRootBindingCount": 0, "frameScriptTileWriteProducerFound": false, "nonObjectPromotedAnimatedProducerCommandCount": 0, "specializedLoopStrongCandidateCount": 0, "drawTimeVisibleMotionTransformFound": false }, "battleSummary": { "helpersWithPositionOrMotion": 84, "helpersWithMotionStep": 34, "skillsWithHelpers": 96, "skillsWithEffectFrames": 92, "skillsWithExecutionRequirements": 52, "motionModelClassifiedRows": 52, "pixelOracleStatus": "not-original-runtime-pixel-oracle" }, "recommendedNextStaticStep": "For map motion, inspect the animated-map load/update dispatcher or any caller that materializes opcode 0x58/0x6b/0x76 streams after resource load; do not continue from palette handlers or strict object frame scripts unless new refs appear." }, "mapSurfaces": [ { "area": "palette ramp/copy", "source": "palette_pipeline_review.json", "status": "palette-buffer-copy-apply-path-grounded", "finding": "The EXE keeps a mutable 256-entry palette buffer at 0x004676e8. Palette effects copy or step RGB bytes inside that buffer, then push a range to DirectDraw with SetEntries. This is a color/fade/ramp pipeline, not proof of tile-position animation.", "promotion": "promoted-color-only", "boundary": "색상/fade/ramp 근거이며 타일 위치/source-index motion 근거는 아니다." }, { "area": "live layer0/layer1 buffer writers", "source": "map_animation_live_buffer_writer_review.json", "status": "live-buffer-writers-grounded-animation-producer-unbound", "finding": "live layer0/layer1 buffer writer handlers are grounded, but their refs are not inside animated-map resource roots and no per-map/per-tick animation producer has been found. Keep visible map animation unpromoted.", "promotion": "handlers-grounded-root-unbound", "boundary": "opcode 0x58/0x6b/0x76 live tile writer는 확인됐지만 animated map root/tick와 연결되지 않았다." }, { "area": "draw-time tile transform", "source": "map_animation_draw_tile_transform_review.json", "status": "draw-time-tile-transform-negative-for-visible-animation", "finding": "The inspected draw path maps the current live layer0 tile id to a source rect by fixed grid math. It does not provide the missing fire/waterfall frame loop.", "promotion": "negative-for-visible-motion", "boundary": "현재 draw path는 live layer0 tile id를 고정 grid 공식으로 source rect에 매핑한다." }, { "area": "field tick route", "source": "map_animation_tick_route_review.json", "status": "tick-route-grounded-producer-still-indirect", "finding": "The field tick/update route is grounded, but it does not directly mutate live map buffers. The remaining static producer candidate is an active-object delayed script executed through 0x00402321.", "promotion": "tick-route-grounded-producer-indirect", "boundary": "per-frame route는 확인됐지만 직접 live map buffer를 mutate하지 않는다." }, { "area": "strict active-object +0xec scripts", "source": "map_animation_active_object_script_tile_write_review.json", "status": "strict-active-object-script-tile-write-not-found", "finding": "No strict active-object +0xec script currently decodes to a command-boundary live tile-write. Raw plausible bytes exist only as unpromoted candidates if present.", "promotion": "negative", "boundary": "strict object script command boundary에서는 live tile write가 나오지 않는다." }, { "area": "runtime-installed object +0x64 frame scripts", "source": "map_animation_frame_script_tile_write_review.json", "status": "object-frame-script-tile-write-not-found", "finding": "Runtime-installed object +0x64 frame scripts are grounded, but neither opcode 0x20 attach targets nor opcode 0x18 state-table entries contain command-boundary live map tile writes.", "promotion": "negative", "boundary": "opcode 0x20 attach target과 0x18 state-table entry 모두 command-boundary tile write가 없다." }, { "area": "non-object aligned tile-write roots", "source": "map_animation_non_object_tile_write_root_review.json", "status": "non-object-tile-write-root-producer-not-found", "finding": "Aligned tile-write VM roots exist, but none both bind to a known animated map root and write a known animated tile/coordinate. The non-object/root scan therefore does not promote the visible fire/waterfall producer.", "promotion": "roots-exist-no-animated-binding", "boundary": "aligned tile-write commands는 있지만 animated map/root + animated coordinate/tile을 동시에 만족하지 않는다." }, { "area": "specialized loop scan", "source": "map_animation_specialized_loop_boundary_review.json", "status": "specialized-map-animation-loop-not-found", "finding": "No inspected tick/redraw/draw window, nor its direct callees, exposes a separate live-buffer/tile-shift producer. The static evidence still stops at redraw invalidation plus generic writer handlers; continue from the animated-map load/update dispatcher.", "promotion": "negative", "boundary": "tick/redraw/draw 주변 direct callee에서도 별도 live-buffer/tile-shift producer를 찾지 못했다." } ], "battleSurfaces": [ { "area": "helper position/motion fields", "source": "battle_helper_position_motion_review.json", "status": "helper-position-motion-field-review", "finding": "84 helpers carry position/motion; 34 carry motion step.", "promotion": "promoted-helper-motion-semantics", "boundary": "전투 helper/object motion은 팔레트가 아니라 object position/motion field 기반으로 해석 가능하다." }, { "area": "effect pattern join", "source": "battle_effect_animation_pattern_review.json", "status": "effect-helper-animation-patterns-joined-by-skill", "finding": "96 skill rows have helpers; 52 rows require spawn/motion execution.", "promotion": "joined-by-skill", "boundary": "스킬별 helper/effect frame 결합은 됐지만 원작 픽셀 오라클은 별도 검증이다." }, { "area": "visual execution assertions", "source": "battle_effect_visual_assertion_review.json", "status": "visual-assertions-pass", "finding": "52 requirement rows have colored previews; pixel oracle status is not-original-runtime-pixel-oracle.", "promotion": "web-runner-asserted-not-original-oracle", "boundary": "웹 runner 표현은 검증됐지만 원작 런타임 캡처와 동일하다고 주장하지 않는다." }, { "area": "motion boundary loops", "source": "battle_motion_boundary_loop_review.json", "status": "motion-boundary-loop-semantics-grounded", "finding": "7 boundary rows, helpers [95, 96, 97, 98].", "promotion": "promoted-loop-semantics", "boundary": "일부 화면 경계/loop형 motion은 정적 분석으로 의미가 확정됐다." } ], "promotionDecisions": [ { "area": "field map palette effects", "decision": "promote as color/ramp only", "reason": "palette buffer/copy/SetEntries path is grounded, but it cannot by itself move waterfall/fire source tiles." }, { "area": "field map visible tile motion", "decision": "keep unpromoted", "reason": "no static producer writes animated-map live layer0 source ids under a proven per-map/per-tick binding." }, { "area": "battle effect helper motion", "decision": "promote for runner use", "reason": "helper position/motion opcode fields and spawn/motion execution requirements are joined by skill and checked by visual assertions." } ], "nextFrontier": [ "Search upstream materializers for tile-write command streams instead of re-scanning decoded +0xec/+0x64 object scripts.", "Separate map tile source-index motion from palette-only effects in every future map animation claim.", "If static search remains saturated, use a narrow runtime watchpoint on 0x00595af0 live layer0 entries for map1_01a/map1_02b animated cells.", "For battle effects, future work should target original-runtime pixel/oracle comparison rather than reclassifying already joined helper motion rows." ] }